June 8, 2021 Blogs, Vlogs, and Webinars, Learning and Reflections

Reflections: Opportunities for how a system shift in practices and policies would support improved safeguarding for child victims of exploitation and improved prosecutions of adult offenders who exploit them

Resource

It is widely recognised that tackling, disrupting and, most importantly, prosecuting offences of modern slavery – specifically those linked to child criminal exploitation (CCE) – remains a significant challenge. 

In the policy arena, the government’s new Tackling Child Sexual Abuse Strategy, alongside building capacity in policing through the National County Lines Coordination Centre and Tackling Organised Exploitation Programme, commits to take firm action to disrupt child exploitation. Yet tackling these pernicious offences requires a multi-layered and systemic approach to change and continual improvement.

There are many reasons why this is always going to be a challenge. Considering the start of the exploitation and grooming process, where too often early warning signs are there but not able to be acted on due to a combination of resource constraints, workforce capability and capacity, and tactics of the exploiter in encouraging young people to refuse or withdraw from support designed to protect them.

However, there are also many points along the exploitation journey where a system shift in the practices and policies would support improved safeguarding for child victims of exploitation and improved prosecutions of adult offenders who exploit them.

One example is how the Tackling Child Exploitation (TCE) Support Programme has been supporting local areas to identify, share, collect, digest and act on data to support strategic leaders to disrupt exploitation more effectively. There is no silver bullet ‘data set’ that can tell us the scale of CCE. However, proxies do exist that highlight an increasingly identifiable group of young people[1]:

  • Figures for Child In Need assessments show ‘gangs’ were highlighted on 14,700 assessments in 2020, a rise from 10,960 in 2019[2].

  • Statistics for the National Referral Mechanism show a comparable rise, with over 5,100 children referred between 1 October 2019 and 31 September 2020, over 2,500 of which were due to concerns of criminal exploitation. Despite these high and rising numbers, prosecutions remain stubbornly low[3].

It is worth taking a moment to reflect on this. We are identifying a cohort of young people at risk or vulnerable to ‘gangs’ (a term which undoubtedly places some blame on the young person themselves), but we are not identifying a comparable number of young people at risk due to CCE. Our mind-set as well as our data needs to change.

Another example is within the Disrupting Exploitation Programme, led by The Children’s Society and funded by The National Lottery Community Fund. The programme has focused on key reachable moments in a young person’s journey through the system to alter the experience and responses to young people who have been criminally exploited. One of these moments, identified through frontline practice and the experience of young people, is when a young person is arrested for crimes linked or attributable to their exploitation. For example, when a young person is arrested for Possession with Intent to Supply (PWITS) and, rather than being prosecuted, is supported through a multi-agency and whole family intervention. 

It remains the case that, too, often this moment follows a predictable trajectory of a decision to charge, criminal proceedings and associated outcomes. When the criminal activity is happening through exploitation, there will be a young person (and often their family also) with a growing distrust and scepticism of a system that sees and treats them as a perpetrator, rather than a victim of exploitation (although often young people can be both).

The legislative framework underpinning this trajectory is complex and, in places, patchy, not sufficiently tailored to the realities of the crimes being committed against young people[4]. There is currently no statutory definition of CCE. And it remains the case that, operationally, the term can become synonymous with the County Lines model of exploitation, meaning young people who commit other offences such as theft are not always considered to be victims of CCE. This is slowly changing through increased training and the sharing of good practice in identifying victims.  

Often key to how a young person is perceived in the criminal justice system is whether or not they are recognised through the National Referral Mechanism (NRM)[5] as a victim of trafficking. Whilst this process is not legally required to access the section 45 defence in the Modern Slavery Act 2015, it is often perceived to be so. A recent High Court decision (DPP v. M) has confirmed the value of the NRM in criminal proceedings[6]

After a young person (M) was arrested and charged, the young person received a conclusive grounds decision on the NRM identifying them as a victim of trafficking.  This was submitted into evidence but later challenged by the prosecution. The importance of this case was that the NRM decision was deemed admissible in court due in part to the expertise involved in NRM decision-making. Decisions on the NRM are made by the Single Competent Authority – for both child and adult victims – where staff are fully trained to help identify victims of human trafficking.

Across The Children’s Society, we hope this ruling provides a moment of reflection to question where criminal cases are pursued inappropriately to the detriment of longer term safeguarding.

We know as a starting point that building awareness of the NRM amongst statutory agencies – who have a legal duty as first responders to refer to the NRM – is key, as is improving awareness of the process more generally. Embedding awareness of the NRM into social work and police curricula, and continued professional development, is critical to the longer-term approach to tackling exploitation. 

Crucially, it can also help build an evidence base for modern slavery prosecutions when intelligence is smartly joined up across the system. After all, we know that working at both ends of the system – early intervention, disruption and prosecution of adult offenders – is necessary to meaningfully and sustainably disrupt child exploitation. 


Footnotes

[1] It is important to note that not all young people at risk of or being exploited are identified in data and that some groups are disproportionately represented.

[2] https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/data-tables/fast-track/0247c828-2398-4d34-8b98-08d884b70554

[3] https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/national-referral-mechanism-statistics

[4] https://www.childrenssociety.org.uk/information/professionals/resources/disrupting-exploitation-proposal-change

[5] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/human-trafficking-victims-referral-and-assessment-forms/guidance-on-the-national-referral-mechanism-for-potential-adult-victims-of-modern-slavery-england-and-wales#:~:text=The%20National%20Referral%20Mechanism%20(%20NRM,involve%20multiple%20forms%20of%20exploitation.

[6] https://www.2bedfordrow.co.uk/modern-slavery-the-section-45-defence-and-the-national-referral-mechanism-clarity-at-last-by-rhys-rosser/

Joining the Dots
Our collective knowledge of and understanding of child exploitation is still a developing field. Ideas and examples from across the sector and beyond may help bring a fresh new perspective or unlock a problem. The resources below are part of this rich conversation...
Read more

Tell us what you think

If you have particular comments or feedback on this resource please let us know.

Give feedback

Accept Our Terms And Conditions

By clicking the ‘Accept’ button you, the user, confirm you have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions of Use of this open source website as part of the Tackling Childhood Exploitation Support Programme.

Terms and Conditions of Use

Please read these Terms and Conditions of Use carefully before you start to use the site. By using our site, you indicate that you accept these Terms and Conditions of Use and that you agree to abide by them. If you do not agree to these Terms and Conditions of Use, please refrain from using our site.

Accessing our site

Access to our site is open and public, and we reserve the right to withdraw or amend the service we provide on our site without notice (see below). We will not be liable if, for any reason, our site is unavailable at any time or for any period.

When using our site, you must comply with the provisions of our Acceptable Use Policy (below). You are responsible for making all arrangements necessary for you to have access to our site. You are also responsible for ensuring that all persons who access our site through your internet connection are aware of these Terms and Conditions of Use, and that they comply with them.

Intellectual property rights

The materials of this website have been gifted in kind or commissioned for the purpose of being open and free to access.

As a user, you may print off multiple copies and may download multiple documents.  These documents must only be used to support your work.  You must not pass on any part of the materials on our site to third parties and you must not use any part of the materials on our site for commercial purposes without obtaining a licence to do so from us or our licensors.

As a user of our site, you must not modify the paper or digital copies of any materials you have printed off or downloaded in any way, and you must not use any illustrations, photographs, video or audio sequences or any graphics separately from any accompanying text.   The status of any identified contributors as the authors of material on our site must always be acknowledged.

The identified contributors are the owner or the licensee of all intellectual property rights in our site, and in the material published on it. Those works are protected by copyright laws and treaties around the world. All such rights are reserved.

All trademarks, service marks, trade names, logos, domain names, and any other features of branding are the sole property of the respective contributors.

Our site changes

We aim to update our site regularly, and may change the content at any time. If the need arises, we may suspend access to our site, or close it indefinitely. Any of the material on our site may be out of date at any given time, and we are under no obligation to update such material.

Our liability

The material displayed on our site is provided without any guarantees, conditions or warranties as to its accuracy. To the extent permitted by law, we, other members of our group of companies and third parties connected to us hereby expressly exclude:

  • All conditions, warranties and other Terms and Conditions of Use which might otherwise be implied by statute, common law or the law of equity.
  • Any liability for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage incurred by any user in connection with our site or in connection with the use, inability to use, or results of the use of our site, any websites linked to it and any materials posted on it, including:
  • loss of income or revenue;
  • loss of business;
  • loss of profits or contracts;
  • loss of anticipated savings;
  • loss of data;
  • loss of goodwill;
  • wasted management or office time; and whether caused by tort (including negligence), breach of contract or otherwise, even if foreseeable, provided that this condition shall not prevent claims for loss of or damage to your tangible property or any other claims for direct financial loss that are not excluded by any of the categories set out above.

This does not affect our liability for death or personal injury arising from our negligence, nor our liability for fraudulent misrepresentation or misrepresentation as to a fundamental matter, nor any other liability which cannot be excluded or limited under applicable law.

Information about you and your visits to our site

We process information about you in accordance with our Privacy Policy. By using our site, you consent to such processing and you warrant that all data provided by you is accurate.

Viruses, hacking and other offences

You must not misuse our site by knowingly introducing viruses, trojans, worms, logic bombs or other material which is malicious or technologically harmful. You must not attempt to gain unauthorised access to our site, the server on which our site is stored or any server, computer or database connected to our site. You must not attack our site via a denial-of-service attack or a distributed denial-of service attack.

By breaching this provision, you would commit a criminal offence under the Computer Misuse Act 1990. We will report any such breach to the relevant law enforcement authorities and we will co-operate with those authorities by disclosing your identity to them. In the event of such a breach, your right to use our site will cease immediately.

We will not be liable for any loss or damage caused by a distributed denial-of-service attack, viruses or other technologically harmful material that may infect your computer equipment, computer programs, data or other proprietary material due to your use of our site or to your downloading of any material posted on it, or on any website linked to it.

Linking to our site

You may link to our home page, provided you do so in a way that is fair and legal and does not damage our reputation or take advantage of it, but you must not establish a link in such a way as to suggest any form of association, approval or endorsement on our part where none exists.

You must not establish a link from any website that is not owned by you.

Our site must not be framed on any other site, nor may you create a link to any part of our site other than the home page. We reserve the right to withdraw linking permission without notice. The website from which you are linking must comply in all respects with the content standards set out in our Acceptable Use Policy (below).

If you wish to make any use of material on our site other than that set out above, please address your request to TCEadmin@researchinpractice.org.uk.

Links from our site

Where our site contains links to other sites and resources provided by third parties, these links are provided for your information only. We have no control over the contents of those sites or resources, and accept no responsibility for them or for any loss or damage that may arise from your use of them.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

The English courts will have non-exclusive jurisdiction over any claim arising from, or related to, a visit to our site although we retain the right to bring proceedings against you for breach of these conditions in your country of residence or any other relevant country.

These Terms and Conditions of Use of use and any dispute or claim arising out of or in connection with them or their subject matter or formation (including non-contractual disputes or claims) shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the law of England and Wales.

International partners

Research in Practice is only able to provide technical support for our web services in English.

In the event of any legal dispute or claim, the courts of England and Wales shall have exclusive jurisdiction.

Storage, retention and access to data will be treated in accordance with our obligations under United Kingdom data protection legislation.


Acceptable Use Policy

Prohibited uses:

You may use our site only for lawful purposes. You may not use our site:

  • In any way that breaches any applicable local, national or international law or regulation.
  • In any way that is unlawful or fraudulent, or has any unlawful or fraudulent purpose or effect.
  • For the purpose of harming or attempting to harm minors in any way.
  • To send, knowingly receive, upload, download, use or re-use any material which does not comply with our content standards (below).
  • To transmit, or procure the sending of, any unsolicited or unauthorised advertising or promotional material or any other form of similar solicitation (spam).
  • To knowingly transmit any data, send or upload any material that contains viruses, Trojan horses, worms, time-bombs, keystroke loggers, spyware, adware or any other harmful programs or similar computer code designed to adversely affect the operation of any computer software or hardware.

You also agree:

  • Not to reproduce, duplicate, copy or re-sell any part of our site in contravention of the provisions of our Terms and Conditions of Use (above).
  • Not to access without authority, interfere with, damage or disrupt:
    • any part of our site;
    • any equipment or network on which our site is stored;
    • any software used in the provision of our site; or
    • any equipment or network or software owned or used by any third party.

Breach of Acceptable Use Policy:

We will determine, in our discretion, whether there has been a breach of this Acceptable Use Policy through your use of our site. When a breach of this policy has occurred, we may take such action as we deem appropriate.

Failure to comply with this Acceptable Use Policy constitutes a material breach of the Terms and Conditions of Use upon which you are permitted to use our site, and may result in our taking all or any of the following actions:

  • Issue of a warning to you.
  • Legal proceedings against you for reimbursement of all costs on an indemnity basis (including, but not limited to, reasonable administrative and legal costs) resulting from the breach.
  • Further legal action against you.
  • Disclosure of such information to law enforcement authorities as we reasonably feel is necessary.

We exclude liability for actions taken in response to breaches of this Acceptable Use Policy. The responses described in this policy are not limited, and we may take any other action we reasonably deem appropriate.

Changes to the Acceptable Use Policy

We may revise this Acceptable Use Policy at any time by amending this page. You are expected to check this page from time to time to take notice of any changes we make, as they are legally binding on you. Some of the provisions contained in this Acceptable Use Policy may also be superseded by provisions or notices published elsewhere on our site.

Your concerns

If you have any concerns about material which appears on our site, please contact TCEadmin@researchinpractice.org.uk.

Thank you for visiting our site.