Child Exploitation Integration, Children and Young People's Voice, Digital Delivery, Learning and Reflections, Programme Priorities

TCE Year 2 Priorities: Children and young people’s voice

Resource

Hello – and welcome 

We are really looking forward to working with you on our action research project on children and young people’s voice. 

Young People’s voice is one of our programme priorities, and our aim is to identify and share ways in which senior leaders can bring children and young people’s voice into strategic discussions about child exploitation and extra familial harm.  This piece of work is being led by Ellie Fairgrieve (The Children’s Society) and Isabelle Brodie (University of Bedfordshire). 

To get this underway, we have scoped examples and evidence of children and young people’s participation work from within the consortium and across the sector.  We’ve also pulled together evidence from TCE’s own learning and evaluation to date, including our sector survey, bespoke support project applications and project learning reports.  

From our initial scoping focused on participation of children and young people’s views into strategic responses to tackle child exploitation, there is some recognition of the importance of children and young people’s views, however, it is not clear how this contributes to decision making within local areas.  Children and young people are too often absent from the debate – and there is uncertainty about what to do about that. 

We want to find out more. 

The next stage of our approach was to talk to the sector via Twitter (@EllieFairgrieve and @uniofbedsCSE). Conducted during November we asked a question a week and collected the responses received. This blog looks at the questions and some of the responses from the sector.

If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to contact us at ellie.fairgrieve@childrenssociety.org.uk / @EllieFairgrieve and Isabelle.brodie@beds.ac.uk / @uniofbedsCSE


Diary #Week 1 – 6th November 2020 

Well, our Twitter conversation is underway!  A huge thanks to everyone who has contributed. 

Our first question for the sector was: what does children and young people’s voice mean to you, as a strategic leader?’  

The thinking behind this question was that we need to know how people understand ‘children and young people’s voice’ before we can go on to consider if, and how this already takes place, or could take place better.   

We know from discussion with the sector and from research literature that many different terms are used in relation to children and young people’s ‘voice’ – participation, consultation, co-creation and so on – and these can also be used in different ways.  People also have different experiences of trying to do this.  And it can be difficult to question what is meant by ‘voice’ in a professional context. 

We were a little unsure the level of response we would get to this first question, but are really pleased that people ‘liked’ the idea and the question, and that discussion is underway.  People reminded us that: 

  • There are young people who are working as strategic advocates, and who are ‘raising their voices’.  It is important to look at different services and sectors, and some responses flagged that there are some really good examples of how young people contribute to strategy in the health sector and elsewhere. 
  • It should not just be thought of as ‘nice’ or an afterthought, but core to what we do. 
  • Things that help facilitate children and young people’s voice include having national champions who keep issues on the agenda, and having dedicated staff who support them. 
  • Involvement needs to be genuine, meaningful and sustained. 
  • Things will go wrong, but that’s OK and it’s important to keep moving forwards. 
  • And a challenge – even if we are trying to ensure children and young people are part of developing strategy, how do we hear, understand and respond to what they are saying? How do we cede power and follow through what young people are saying to decision making? And most importantly, how do we feedback to young people about what action has been taken as a result of their input? 

These are all really important points, and an essential foundation to the way we proceed in our thinking about the children and young people’s strand of work in our Tackling Child Exploitation (TCE) programme.  

This is a new way of working for both of us, and is also new to TCE as a programme – and we know there is still a lot to learn.  Next week we’re planning to extend our Twitter reach and perhaps be more pro-active within the conversation.  We also need to follow up on some of the examples we’ve been given. 

Thank you again, and we look forward to talking more! 


Diary #Week 2 – 13th November 2020 

Both Isabelle and I are so pleased with the engagement we have received from our Twitter conversations so far – it’s been wonderful to hear from so many of you, especially connecting with colleagues across the sector that we haven’t previously met.  

Our second question was: what is your approach to engaging CYP (Children and Young People) in participation work to inform strategic work to develop child exploitation and extra-familial harm responses? 

What we hoped this question would achieve is for us to increase the sector’s understanding of how senior leaders are working with children and young people, and to share approaches to encourage others to do so. Approaches across the sector can vary significantly, from engaging young people in participation work to informing a campaign or design a service specificationHowever, we wanted to probe a little further to identify specific examples and to consider what skills are specifically required from us as senior leaders to enable meaningful participation.  

Some of the examples of approaches we heard about were: 

  • Build requirement to coproduce service with young people into the contract/commissioning process” 
  • “Young person led social media campaigns” 
  • “Through the development of a trusted relationship it enabled young people to see the system problems, and for them not to face it as ‘my problem’” 
  • “Gathering insights from 1:1 work and looking at themes across the board in order to use these themes to inform decisions about which systems we focus on in our systems change work” 
  • “Co-designed an exploitation model with young people. Young people designed the tools, the pathways and practice standards to develop the complex safeguarding model to respond to exploitation” 
  • “We have recently used music and graffiti sessions to enable young people to describe their experiences and we are using these messages to update our campaigns, interventions, and overall approach to engagement with children and young people” 
  • “Young people have been part of our recruitment strategy and interviews for staff across the service. 
  • “Open access participation – explaining the project, how young people can be involved if they want to – being ok that young people will dip in and out as they choose and they are welcomed back when they are ready” 
     

Something to consider further is the importance of placing participation at the core of all our activities and decisions we make. What would our strategies and action plans look like then? We think they would look different with children’s and young people’s input.  

We recognise that is helpful for us to share how young people can participate, but equally important is: what are the skills required from us to enable meaningful participation? 

  • Investment of time and energy to move beyond feedback to collaborative service design 
  • Listen with intent to stop young people feeling as though “you keep asking us but no-one listens” 
  • Be open to self-reflection – is my approach to participation achieving what I hoped for? If not, who can help me? 
  • Be brave to act and work creatively – the best of ideas come from stepping outside our comfort zones and trying new approaches. If we do not try, how will we know?  
  • Work hard to share power and control and as Abianda described “Work in a non-hierarchical way to challenge unequal dynamics power & oppression” 
  • Ask open questions e.g., “what needs to change?” 
  • Embed feedback loops. Let’s stop asking young people for their involvement and then not giving them feedback on how their input has contributed or influenced the work 
  • Being honest with young people about where/how the request has come about and what you would like from their involvement
  • Respect young people – respect their views, respect their knowledge and experiences of their own lives , respect their contribution and respect that what we may want to hear might not be the answer we receive.  

We will be using these skills to inform our work on the TCE programme. 

Next week we’re looking forward to more engagement and wanting to understand what the barriers are in engaging CYP in participation work to inform strategic responses for child exploitation and extra-familial harm

Thank you again, and we look forward to talking more! 


Diary #Week 3 – 20th November 2020 

As the weeks go on, we are accumulating a store of ideas and insights.  So far, it has been clear that those responding feel strongly that children and young people’s involvement in strategic discussion and decision making about child exploitation should be part of the fabric of work in the sector.  It should not be an optional extra. 

Of course, it can reasonably be argued we are talking to the converted – our Twitter audience consists of people and organisations who are signed up to the idea that children and young people should, and have a right to, participate in strategic decision making. 

Maybe that Twitter bubble is replicated in other contexts, both organisationally and at policy level?  Who are we missing? Are we talking to people who don’t agree, or have reservations and don’t feel able to voice them? And if we are not, then how do we reach them? 

It is also clear that examples of such participation are often presented as exceptional, and therefore unusual, practice.  So we wanted to explore that gap more. 

Our third question was: What is stopping us from engaging children and young people in participation work to inform strategic responses for child exploitation and extra-familial harm? 

We got fewer responses this week – perhaps because people feel they’ve already answered this in other comments.  However, some interesting themes nevertheless emerged about the perceived barriers. 

The key themes emerging from this discussion were: 

  • Commitment is essential, and is too often lacking – especially from senior leaders.  Not everyone recognises the fundamental value of working with young people to enable them to participate.
  • Funding for services – austerity and other policy decisions have reduced investment in services for young people.  Many services have disappeared. 
  • As well as funding for services, the way in which resources are spent is also important.  People said that funding is also needed to give workers the time and skills they need to work with young people in a relationship based way.   Young people need to have access to different opportunities in sport, arts, music that will extend their skills and resilience, and enable services to support their participation.   
  • Language is important, and can obscure what is happening – for example, what do people really mean when they say that there has been a consultation with young people?  Would young people agree – and if so, which young people?  We need to be more honest about what is going on!   
  • Young people’s previous experiences of services, including instances where they do not feel they have been listened to or where no action has been taken in response to their views. 
  • Leadership is key – senior leaders need to be able to invest time and resources in their staff so that they can work to develop relationships with young people, that will in turn create opportunities for participation in services.  They also need to be “brave enough to take on board what CYP have said, even though some of it may go against the grain of our usual approaches”.  

All these points need further exploration.  For example, if there is lack of commitment, why is this? Have people tried a participative approach, and found it too difficult – or felt hamstrung by lack of resource or support? 

We are now starting to think about what the next stages of this project will involve – if you have any thoughts, please don’t hesitate to contact us on Twitter @isabellebrodie4 or @EllieFairgrieve or by email ellie.fairgrieve@childrenssociety.org.uk and Isabelle.brodie@beds.ac.uk


Diary #Week 4 – 27th November 2020 

Isabelle and I have taken some time this week to think further about the responses we have received so far enquiring about how the sector engages young people’s voices in strategic decisions, and especially about how we can utilise this opportunity to make a difference and contribute to this space.  

This week we reached our final week of asking our set of Twitter questions. In case you missed it, we asked ‘what support or information do you need to engage children and young people into the strategic dialogue?’ 

Our week 3 diary entry is proof of the pudding that our Twitter audience consists of people and organisations who are signed up to the idea that children and young people should participate in strategic decision making! We did not get as much engagement this week but I truly believe it is because our question did not reach those who may be able to share some suggestions.  

@nerysanthony responded with

 “Not sure it’s support or information but a recognition that this takes time and any involvement needs to be in the interests of the young person. Not just because strategy development would be better for their involvement”  

And we could not agree more. We have discussed how we do not feel that senior leaders do not want to include young people in strategic decisions or do not know how to but there might be conditions senior leaders and partnerships need to enable this to take place, including the letting-go of power. 

Some of the wider activity taking place in the TCE Programme may be helpful in thinking about this. We have been working with some of my The Children’s Society colleagues from the Accelerating Impact team – @gemmadrake to explore the long-term system change goal that TCE is working towards (more about that another time).This week we explored the enabling conditions the TCE programme needs to support local areas to develop strategic responses to child exploitation and extra-familial harm. Some of the enabling conditions discussed that initially come to mind are:  

  • Holding a space with sufficient and quality time to be able to focus and conduct participation 
  • An enthusiasm and drive for collaboration and co-production at a strategic level 
  • Access to the system – having and giving permission with stakeholders and sharing information, knowledge and experiences 
  • Permission to challenge – how we get comfortable with being uncomfortable. We referenced this in our week two blog that a skill required to enable meaningful participation is to respect young people and respect that what we may want to hear might not be the answer we receive.  

And these are just a few! We would be interested in hearing what you perceive the enabling conditions may be for senior leaders to engage children and young people’s voice into strategic discussion about child exploitation and extra familial harm. 


So that is the end of our Twitter questions (for now!) We are in the process of drafting what our next set of actions will be – we guarantee this will involve consulting with young people but if you have any ideas or want to contribute to our work please do contact us on Twitter: @EllieFairgrieve or @isabellebrodie4 or by email: ellie.fairgrieve@childrenssociety.org.uk and Isabelle.brodie@beds.ac.uk  

Ellie and Isabelle  

Tell us what you think

If you have particular comments or feedback on this resource please let us know.

Give feedback

Accept Our Terms And Conditions

By clicking the ‘Accept’ button you, the user, confirm you have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions of Use of this open source website as part of the Tackling Childhood Exploitation Support Programme.

Terms and Conditions of Use

Please read these Terms and Conditions of Use carefully before you start to use the site. By using our site, you indicate that you accept these Terms and Conditions of Use and that you agree to abide by them. If you do not agree to these Terms and Conditions of Use, please refrain from using our site.

Accessing our site

Access to our site is open and public, and we reserve the right to withdraw or amend the service we provide on our site without notice (see below). We will not be liable if, for any reason, our site is unavailable at any time or for any period.

When using our site, you must comply with the provisions of our Acceptable Use Policy (below). You are responsible for making all arrangements necessary for you to have access to our site. You are also responsible for ensuring that all persons who access our site through your internet connection are aware of these Terms and Conditions of Use, and that they comply with them.

Intellectual property rights

The materials of this website have been gifted in kind or commissioned for the purpose of being open and free to access.

As a user, you may print off multiple copies and may download multiple documents.  These documents must only be used to support your work.  You must not pass on any part of the materials on our site to third parties and you must not use any part of the materials on our site for commercial purposes without obtaining a licence to do so from us or our licensors.

As a user of our site, you must not modify the paper or digital copies of any materials you have printed off or downloaded in any way, and you must not use any illustrations, photographs, video or audio sequences or any graphics separately from any accompanying text.   The status of any identified contributors as the authors of material on our site must always be acknowledged.

The identified contributors are the owner or the licensee of all intellectual property rights in our site, and in the material published on it. Those works are protected by copyright laws and treaties around the world. All such rights are reserved.

All trademarks, service marks, trade names, logos, domain names, and any other features of branding are the sole property of the respective contributors.

Our site changes

We aim to update our site regularly, and may change the content at any time. If the need arises, we may suspend access to our site, or close it indefinitely. Any of the material on our site may be out of date at any given time, and we are under no obligation to update such material.

Our liability

The material displayed on our site is provided without any guarantees, conditions or warranties as to its accuracy. To the extent permitted by law, we, other members of our group of companies and third parties connected to us hereby expressly exclude:

  • All conditions, warranties and other Terms and Conditions of Use which might otherwise be implied by statute, common law or the law of equity.
  • Any liability for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage incurred by any user in connection with our site or in connection with the use, inability to use, or results of the use of our site, any websites linked to it and any materials posted on it, including:
  • loss of income or revenue;
  • loss of business;
  • loss of profits or contracts;
  • loss of anticipated savings;
  • loss of data;
  • loss of goodwill;
  • wasted management or office time; and whether caused by tort (including negligence), breach of contract or otherwise, even if foreseeable, provided that this condition shall not prevent claims for loss of or damage to your tangible property or any other claims for direct financial loss that are not excluded by any of the categories set out above.

This does not affect our liability for death or personal injury arising from our negligence, nor our liability for fraudulent misrepresentation or misrepresentation as to a fundamental matter, nor any other liability which cannot be excluded or limited under applicable law.

Information about you and your visits to our site

We process information about you in accordance with our Privacy Policy. By using our site, you consent to such processing and you warrant that all data provided by you is accurate.

Viruses, hacking and other offences

You must not misuse our site by knowingly introducing viruses, trojans, worms, logic bombs or other material which is malicious or technologically harmful. You must not attempt to gain unauthorised access to our site, the server on which our site is stored or any server, computer or database connected to our site. You must not attack our site via a denial-of-service attack or a distributed denial-of service attack.

By breaching this provision, you would commit a criminal offence under the Computer Misuse Act 1990. We will report any such breach to the relevant law enforcement authorities and we will co-operate with those authorities by disclosing your identity to them. In the event of such a breach, your right to use our site will cease immediately.

We will not be liable for any loss or damage caused by a distributed denial-of-service attack, viruses or other technologically harmful material that may infect your computer equipment, computer programs, data or other proprietary material due to your use of our site or to your downloading of any material posted on it, or on any website linked to it.

Linking to our site

You may link to our home page, provided you do so in a way that is fair and legal and does not damage our reputation or take advantage of it, but you must not establish a link in such a way as to suggest any form of association, approval or endorsement on our part where none exists.

You must not establish a link from any website that is not owned by you.

Our site must not be framed on any other site, nor may you create a link to any part of our site other than the home page. We reserve the right to withdraw linking permission without notice. The website from which you are linking must comply in all respects with the content standards set out in our Acceptable Use Policy (below).

If you wish to make any use of material on our site other than that set out above, please address your request to TCEadmin@researchinpractice.org.uk.

Links from our site

Where our site contains links to other sites and resources provided by third parties, these links are provided for your information only. We have no control over the contents of those sites or resources, and accept no responsibility for them or for any loss or damage that may arise from your use of them.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

The English courts will have non-exclusive jurisdiction over any claim arising from, or related to, a visit to our site although we retain the right to bring proceedings against you for breach of these conditions in your country of residence or any other relevant country.

These Terms and Conditions of Use of use and any dispute or claim arising out of or in connection with them or their subject matter or formation (including non-contractual disputes or claims) shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the law of England and Wales.

International partners

Research in Practice is only able to provide technical support for our web services in English.

In the event of any legal dispute or claim, the courts of England and Wales shall have exclusive jurisdiction.

Storage, retention and access to data will be treated in accordance with our obligations under United Kingdom data protection legislation.


Acceptable Use Policy

Prohibited uses:

You may use our site only for lawful purposes. You may not use our site:

  • In any way that breaches any applicable local, national or international law or regulation.
  • In any way that is unlawful or fraudulent, or has any unlawful or fraudulent purpose or effect.
  • For the purpose of harming or attempting to harm minors in any way.
  • To send, knowingly receive, upload, download, use or re-use any material which does not comply with our content standards (below).
  • To transmit, or procure the sending of, any unsolicited or unauthorised advertising or promotional material or any other form of similar solicitation (spam).
  • To knowingly transmit any data, send or upload any material that contains viruses, Trojan horses, worms, time-bombs, keystroke loggers, spyware, adware or any other harmful programs or similar computer code designed to adversely affect the operation of any computer software or hardware.

You also agree:

  • Not to reproduce, duplicate, copy or re-sell any part of our site in contravention of the provisions of our Terms and Conditions of Use (above).
  • Not to access without authority, interfere with, damage or disrupt:
    • any part of our site;
    • any equipment or network on which our site is stored;
    • any software used in the provision of our site; or
    • any equipment or network or software owned or used by any third party.

Breach of Acceptable Use Policy:

We will determine, in our discretion, whether there has been a breach of this Acceptable Use Policy through your use of our site. When a breach of this policy has occurred, we may take such action as we deem appropriate.

Failure to comply with this Acceptable Use Policy constitutes a material breach of the Terms and Conditions of Use upon which you are permitted to use our site, and may result in our taking all or any of the following actions:

  • Issue of a warning to you.
  • Legal proceedings against you for reimbursement of all costs on an indemnity basis (including, but not limited to, reasonable administrative and legal costs) resulting from the breach.
  • Further legal action against you.
  • Disclosure of such information to law enforcement authorities as we reasonably feel is necessary.

We exclude liability for actions taken in response to breaches of this Acceptable Use Policy. The responses described in this policy are not limited, and we may take any other action we reasonably deem appropriate.

Changes to the Acceptable Use Policy

We may revise this Acceptable Use Policy at any time by amending this page. You are expected to check this page from time to time to take notice of any changes we make, as they are legally binding on you. Some of the provisions contained in this Acceptable Use Policy may also be superseded by provisions or notices published elsewhere on our site.

Your concerns

If you have any concerns about material which appears on our site, please contact TCEadmin@researchinpractice.org.uk.

Thank you for visiting our site.